TapAFix

Home Improvement Contractor vs. DIY: When to Hire a Professional and When to Do It Yourself

You may think that the home project you’ve been thinking of doing will be more than easy to do. Paint the room. Replace the cabinet handles. Install new flooring. Perhaps even take down a wall to create a larger area.

Now the question is, should you do it yourself or rather hire a professional? DIY can help to save money and give you total control. However, it sometimes takes more time than anticipated. A little mistake can cost a lot on a repair!

A home improvement contractor will be more expensive up front, but you will get knowledge, tools, experience and planning.

The right choice will depend on the project, finances, and risk tolerance you can take. 

When Is DIY a Good Idea?

It’s best for small-scale projects that will not create a significant problem and are relatively easy to fix. Good examples include:

  • Painting walls and trim
  • Hanging shelves and pictures
  • Installing curtain rods
  • Changing cabinet hardware
  • Patching small drywall holes
  • Assembling furniture
  • Installing click-lock flooring
  • To make simple cosmetic changes

These projects are usually not structural or involve major systems and do not have a significant impact on your home. If the paint color is incorrect, repainting the color can be done. Any crooked shelf can be straightened.

That is quite unlike an electrical wiring or plumbing error in the back of a wall. 

DIY Can Save Money, But There Is a Catch

The biggest reason people choose DIY is simple: labor costs money. A general contractor can charge CAD 75 to CAD 120 an hour and a handyman can charge CAD 60 to CAD 120 an hour, depending on the job and the handyman.

This work may cut down on expenses if you do it yourself. Consider tools you will need, supplies, and the amount of time you are available to dedicate to it prior to beginning.

It may be necessary to purchase or lease machines. This will require accompanying materials to be brought in also. It could involve working late nights or during weekends.

Your work may be spread over a complete weekend. A knowledgeable pro can likely be done in a single day. If you are thinking of doing it yourself, therefore, make sure you ask yourself if you will save time and if it is worth it. 

When Should You Hire A Home Improvement Contractor?

There are some projects that do not require experimentation. If you’re considering hiring a licensed contractor, take into account the following:

  • Removing load-bearing walls
  • Major structural changes
  • Home additions
  • Electrical panel upgrades
  • Rewiring
  • Major plumbing changes
  • Gas-related work
  • HVAC installation
  • Roof replacement
  • Basement waterproofing
  • Major framing
  • Extensive bathroom renovations

These projects may result in alterations to your home’s safety, structure or critical systems. Painting mistakes are both inconvenient and an eyesore. Errors with walls that carry weight or electrical wiring can be risky and costly.

What About Smaller Repairs?

You don’t always need a large renovation company. A general contractor, handyman, or specialist may be enough for smaller jobs such as:

  • Drywall repairs
  • Door repairs
  • Minor plumbing
  • Furniture assembly
  • Carpentry
  • Fixture installation
  • Smart home installation
  • Appliance repairs

That’s where home improvement services come in handy. Professional assistance can be obtained without embarking on an expensive renovation project.

Don’t Forget About Permits

Work done by the homeowner does not exclude the need for permit. Permit requirements vary according to the type of work in Toronto. There are some structural changes, additions, and some plumbing and heating changes that may necessitate a building permit. Depending on the project size, some smaller projects, like plumbing fixture replacement, may not need one.

Make sure to review the requirements prior to starting. This can cause difficulties when you go to sell your property in the future or during future inspections. 

Be Careful With Electrical Work

Extra caution should be used when doing electrical work. Ontario Electrical Contractors for hire are required to be licensed by the Electrical Safety Authority.

For rewiring, electrical panel replacement projects and any other large electrical installations, contact the right professional.

It’s not worth the few hundred dollars to cause safety issues. 

DIY vs Hiring A Contractor

Factor

DIY

Contractor

Labour cost

Low

Higher

Time

More of your time

Usually faster

Tools

You provide them

Usually provided

Expertise

Learn as you go

Professional experience

Complex work

Higher risk

Better suited

Permits

You check requirements

May provide guidance

Mistakes

You pay to fix them

May have warranty protection

  • Do It Yourself could be the obvious solution for a simple painting job. 
  • Sometimes, it’s worth investing in experience when it comes to an extensive renovation. 

How To Choose A Contractor

If you do choose a professional contractor, it doesn’t mean that you should go with the lowest bidder. Ask for:

  • Relevant licences or certifications
  • Liability insurance
  • References
  • Written estimates
  • Project timeline
  • Payment schedule
  • Warranty details

If it’s a larger project, be sure to receive at least three written quotes to compare the actual work scope.

Be sure not to compare only the final number.

The one quote may contain materials, clean-up, and warranty as well, while the other only covers labour. Make sure to have written contracts for home improvement contractor work and have terms of payment outlined. 

When A Residential Contractor Makes Sense

A residential contractor may come in handy if the project entails multiple trades.

One of the examples is a kitchen remodel which may need plumbing, electric, cabinets, flooring and painting.

Assuming responsibility for managing all those employees can easily turn into a full-time job.

A home remodeling contractor will be able to arrange various trades, arrange the timetables and ensure that the project is moving forward.

You’re spending your money on more than just labour. That is also experience and coordination that you’re paying for. 

What If You Only Need One Small Job?

Not all house problems require a big contractor. A service marketplace can help find you the electrician, plumber, carpenter, appliance repair person or other professionals you need.

People can find and book a professional for their needs without having to contact multiple companies and wait for them to call back.

TapAFix enables Canadian homeowners to schedule trusted service providers via the app, depending on the service required for their everyday repair and maintenance needs. 

A Simple Rule To Follow

Still unsure whether to DIY? Ask yourself:

1. Is the project cosmetic? 

If yes, DIY home repair may be fine.

2. Does it affect the home’s structure? 

Consider hiring a professional.

3. Does it involve electrical, plumbing, HVAC, or gas systems? 

Professional help is usually safer.

4. Does it require a permit? 

Check local requirements first.

5. Could one mistake cause serious damage? 

Don’t make the project your experiment.

In Summary

Do It Yourself can be a terrific opportunity to save a bit of money and gain a little ability. Small cosmetic changes like painting, assembling furniture etc. are often good projects to do yourself.

However, the major structural, electrical, plumbing, HVAC and roofing jobs are quite different.

Know your limits. If the task is easy, and poses little danger, grab the tools and go for a try. If it’s a serious safety concern or requires special expertise, use the services of a home improvement contractor who has the necessary experience.

The best way is not to do everything or to hire on everything. It’s just that you know which jobs you should do yourself and which ones you could leave to the professionals. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What does a home improvement contractor company do? 

A home improvement contractor company can work on home improvement projects that include renovation, repair, upgrading, remodeling, and additional home projects, as well as coordinating various trades.

Who are the top 10 builders in Canada? 

Here are 10 well known names: PCL Construction, EllisDon, Aecon, Bird Construction, Ledcor, Mattamy Homes, Brookfield Properties, Chandos Construction, Clark Construction Management, and Graham Construction.  

What is the average salary for a contractor? 

The Government of Canada Job Bank says the median pay for a construction general contractor is about CAD 48.72 per hour.  

What are the top 10 construction companies? 

Major construction companies in Canada include PCL Construction, EllisDon, Aecon, Bird Construction, Ledcor, Graham Construction, Chandos Construction, Clark Construction Management, Kiewit Canada, and AtkinsRéalis.